12 Feb India’s Digital Services Tax: Discriminatory?
Posted at 12 Feb 2021 in Current Affairs, Economy, GS Paper II, GS Paper III, International relation 0 Comments
- Recently, a United States Trade Representative (USTR) investigation found India’s Digital Services Tax (DST) to be biased.
- It mentioned that the tax is not consistent with prevailing principles of international taxation. It burdens as well as restricts U.S. commerce.
- India has rebuffed these charges.
Digital Services Tax:
- A DST is a tax on selected gross revenue streams of extensive digital companies. Each country’s ex[ected or implemented DST varies slightly.
- All DSTs have domestic and global revenue brinks, below which companies are not subject to the tax.
- India inducted a six percent equalization duty in 2016. From then to taxing a wider basket of e-services in 2020.
- The fact that a 2% tax, India has charged since 2020 on revenues from digital services, applicable only to non-resident companies.
- The primary matter was that companies don’t have a physical presence in the markets where they conduct their business.
- India, in 2018, had introduced a test for compelling economic presence in the Income Tax Act, according to which, if a company had users in India, it sort of interpreted its economic connection with India, and hence gave India the right to tax.
- One of the focal criticisms against India’s equalization levy is that it is a tax on revenue as compared to a tax on profits. The U.K. allows companies to not pay any tax if their net margin is in the loss.
- As the US claims the law is arbitrary but there are several areas that are not in conformity with what could be a valid reason to call a particular act discriminatory.
- This confrontation could affect the bilateral relationship between the two countries as well as the reputation that it might send globally could be devastating to the Indian economy.
- The act, at best, could be termed as unreasonable but not discriminatory.