Supreme Court hearing on challenges to the Forest Rights Act (FRA), 114 Adivasi rights bodies and environmental groups have urged Union Tribal Affairs Minister Jual Oram to defend the 2006 law, which protects forest rights of tribal and forest-dwelling communities. The FRA has been contested since 2008 by Wildlife First, an NGO advocating for the eviction of those whose FRA claims were rejected. In 2019, the Supreme Court ordered evictions, but after protests, the Ministry intervened, citing procedural errors and wrongful rejections of claims. The court stayed the eviction and called for detailed data on rejected claims.
What is the Forest Rights Act (FRA) 2006?
The Forest Rights Act (FRA), 2006, also known as the Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, is a landmark legislation in India aimed at recognizing and securing the rights of forest-dwelling tribal communities and other traditional forest dwellers over forest resources. The Act was enacted to address historical injustices that these communities faced due to displacement and denial of their rights to forest land and resources.
Key features of Forest Rights Act (FRA) 2006
1. Recognition of Rights: The Forest Rights Act (FRA) 2006 grants several key rights to forest dwellers: Individual Rights for self-cultivation and habitation, Community Rights for grazing, fishing, and forest management, Habitat Rights for PVTGs to live in their traditional habitats, Nomadic and Pastoral Rights for access to seasonal resources and migratory routes, and Community Forest Rights to protect and manage forest resources sustainably.
2. Empowerment of Gram Sabha: The Gram Sabha (village assembly) plays a key role in determining and protecting the rights of forest dwellers, empowering them to manage forest resources at the local level.
3. Prevention of Eviction Without Rehabilitation: Ensures that tribal populations and forest dwellers are not evicted without proper rehabilitation, aligning with the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation, and Settlement Act, 2013.
4. Protection of Biodiversity: Forest dwellers are involved in conserving biodiversity and wildlife and maintaining ecological balance.
5. Developmental Rights: Provides rights to allocate forest land for essential infrastructure such as schools, healthcare centres, and community facilities.
Achievement of Forest Rights Act (FRA) 2006
1. Recognition of Rights: The FRA has successfully recognized the rights of forest-dwelling tribal communities and other traditional forest dwellers, granting them legal ownership of forest land and resources that they have depended on for generations.
2. Empowerment of Gram Sabha: The Act has empowered local communities through the Gram Sabha (village council), allowing them to actively participate in decision-making regarding forest management and resource allocation.
3. Prevention of Unlawful Evictions: The FRA has protected tribal and forest-dwelling communities from unlawful eviction, ensuring that they cannot be displaced without proper rehabilitation and compensation.
4. Sustainable Forest Management: The Act encourages sustainable forest resource management by recognizing the rights of communities to conserve and protect their forests, contributing to biodiversity conservation and ecosystem maintenance.
5. Improved Livelihoods: By granting rights to access forest resources like grazing, fishing, and minor forest produce, the FRA has improved the livelihoods and food security of forest-dwelling communities.
6. Protection of Vulnerable Groups: The Act has specifically addressed the needs of Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTGs), ensuring they retain access to their traditional habitats and resources.
7. Inclusive Development: The FRA has facilitated inclusive development by ensuring that tribal communities have access to basic services like education, healthcare, and infrastructure, promoting social and economic upliftment.
Issue with Forest Rights Act (FRA) 2006 Implementations
1. Slow and Delayed Implementation: The process of recognizing and vesting forest rights has been slow due to delays in forming Forest Rights Committees (FRCs) and holding Gram Sabha meetings for verification and approval.
2. Lack of Awareness: Many forest-dwelling communities are unaware of their rights under FRA, leading to under-reporting of claims and missed opportunities for recognition.
3. Bureaucratic Hurdles: The involvement of multiple government agencies often causes delays and confusion in the implementation process. Bureaucratic inefficiencies can result in prolonged recognition of rights.
4. Opposition from Forest Departments: Forest departments sometimes resist the implementation of FRA, particularly in areas where it conflicts with conservation priorities or forest management strategies.
5. Disputes and Conflicts Over Land: Land disputes often arise, especially in cases where claims are unclear or contested. These disputes can lead to prolonged legal battles and uncertainty for forest communities.
6. Evictions Despite Legal Protections: In some cases, forest-dwelling communities are being evicted despite the legal provision that no evictions should occur until rights are recognized and verified.
7. Inadequate Monitoring and Enforcement: There is a lack of independent monitoring and accountability to ensure that the rights of forest communities are upheld and that the FRA is properly enforced.
8. Conflicts Between Rights and Conservation Goals: Balancing the rights of forest-dwelling communities with the need for conservation, especially in critical wildlife habitats, has led to conflicts regarding land use and resource management.
9. Inequities in Beneficiaries: The process of recognizing rights sometimes favours certain groups over others, leading to inequities in the distribution of forest rights, especially in areas with large tribal populations or diverse communities.
10. Lack of Support for Implementation: There is inadequate support, both financially and in terms of capacity-building, for Gram Sabhas and local authorities responsible for implementing FRA.
Way to make the Forest Rights Act (FRA) 2006 to protect the rights
1. Increase Awareness and Education: Conduct awareness campaigns to inform forest-dwelling communities, Gram Sabhas, and local authorities about the FRA’s provisions and processes. This can help ensure that everyone is informed of their rights and responsibilities under the law.
2. Capacity Building for Gram Sabhas and Forest Rights Committees (FRCs): Train local communities, Gram Sabhas, and FRCs to effectively carry out the process of identifying and verifying claims. This includes providing technical assistance and resources to ensure proper documentation and decision-making.
3. Streamline the Verification and Recognition Process: Simplify and speed up the process for verifying claims by setting clear deadlines and guidelines. Introduce digital tools and geospatial technology to aid in the efficient verification and mapping of forest rights.
4. Strengthen Monitoring and Accountability Mechanisms: Establish independent monitoring bodies to track the implementation of FRA. These bodies should ensure that forest rights are being recognized fairly, that there is no corruption or bias, and that communities are not evicted without due process.
5. Create a Legal and Institutional Framework for Dispute Resolution: Set up dispute resolution mechanisms to handle conflicts related to the recognition of forest rights. This can include setting up local tribunals or committees that can quickly resolve disputes over land claims.
6. Ensure Protection Against Forced Evictions: Strictly enforce the provision that no forest-dwelling community should be evicted until their rights have been recognized and verified. In cases where evictions are necessary, a resettlement package should be provided, ensuring livelihood security.
7. Promote Co-Management of Forest Resources: Encourage co-management of forest resources by forest communities and the forest department. This would ensure that the conservation goals of the state are balanced with the livelihood and cultural needs of forest-dwelling communities, leading to more sustainable forest management practices.
8. Strengthen Legal Support and Advocacy: Provide legal aid and advocacy support to communities facing challenges in claiming or protecting their rights. Collaboration with NGOs and legal professionals can help ensure that forest communities have the resources they need to assert their rights and address any challenges in the process.
Conclusion
No Comments