New Election Commission Appointment: A Closer Look at the ECI and Recent Reforms

20 Feb New Election Commission Appointment: A Closer Look at the ECI and Recent Reforms

SYLLABUS MAPPING:

GS-2-Governance, Constitution, Polity- New Election Commission Appointment: A Closer Look at the ECI and Recent Reforms

FOR PRELIMS 

Current system of appointing the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and other Election Commissioners under the Election Commission (CEC and ECs) Act, 2023.

FOR MAINS

Why in the news:

The Election Commission of India (ECI) has gained attention due to recent developments around appointments, reforms, and the Election Commission (CEC and ECs) Act, 2023. The appointment of a new Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) has sparked debates over the independence and autonomy of the ECI, particularly ahead of the 2024-2025 general elections and state elections. Concerns have emerged regarding the Commission’s ability to function impartially and without political interference while upholding its role in ensuring free, fair, and transparent elections across India.

Constitutional Provisions Related to the Election Commission of India:

The Election Commission of India (ECI), an autonomous constitutional body, is responsible for conducting national and state elections, as outlined in Article 324 of the Indian Constitution. This article vests the authority to oversee elections with the President of India, based on the advice and supervision of the ECI. The Commission conducts elections to the Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha, State Assemblies, and key offices like the President and Vice President. Additionally, it ensures compliance with the Election Code of Conduct and resolves electoral disputes. Initially comprising a Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and two other Election Commissioners, the ECI’s structure has evolved, with the 2023 reform legislation providing a clearer framework for the appointment and functioning of the CEC and ECs.

What is the ECI and the ECI (Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners) Act 2023:

In 2023, the Indian Parliament passed the Election Commission (Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners) Act, a significant reform aimed at addressing long-standing concerns about the ECI’s functioning. The Act provides a more structured and transparent framework for the appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and other Election Commissioners (ECs).Under the new law, the selection process for the CEC and ECs is overseen by a six-member panel comprising:
1. Prime Minister
2. Leader of the Opposition
3. Union Home Minister
4. Chief Justice of India
5. Two eminent persons nominated by a committee
This development addresses concerns over political influence in the appointment process. The Act aims to establish a more impartial and transparent selection mechanism by including diverse perspectives in the decision-making process. The Act also formalizes the tenure and removal process of CECs and ECs. The term of office for the CEC and ECs is fixed at six years or until the age of 65, whichever comes first. Any removal of a sitting Election Commissioner can only occur through a parliamentary impeachment process, which offers a safeguard against arbitrary dismissals.

Features of the CEC & EC Act 2023

1. Appointment Procedure : One of the key aspects of the 2023 Act is the clarification of the appointment procedure for the CEC and Election Commissioners. Under the new law, the President is required to appoint the CEC and ECs based on a recommendation from a six-member selection panel, which will include the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, the Union Home Minister, and the Chief Justice of India. This attempt at bipartisanship aims to reduce political interference in the appointment process, making it more transparent and fair.
2. Term and Removal of CEC & ECs: The Act specifies that both the CEC and ECs shall hold office for a term of six years or until they turn 65, whichever comes earlier. This ensures that the Election Commission retains a sense of continuity in leadership and governance. Furthermore, the process of removing a CEC or an EC has been clearly defined under the Act, with the provision of a parliamentary impeachment procedure if they are to be removed from office. This legal safeguard prevents the arbitrary removal of Election Commissioners.
3. Independence and Accountability: A significant feature of the new law is the emphasis on the autonomy of the Election Commission. The Act aims to ensure that the Election Commission functions without fear or favor, thereby ensuring impartiality in the electoral process. The Act also establishes the legal safeguards necessary to prevent political interference in the functioning of the Commission.
4.Autonomy:The Act emphasizes administrative independence for the Election Commission, aiming to reduce political influence over the Commission’s operations, particularly during election periods.
5. Revised Electoral Code of Conduct: The Act also introduces clearer guidelines for the electoral code of conduct, further reinforcing its role in ensuring that elections are conducted fairly, without undue influence from external forces. This feature aims to reduce malpractices and encourage transparency during elections.

Issues with the CEC & EC Act 2023

1. Executive Overreach:: Although the Act’s intention is to create a more transparent appointment process, the role of the Prime Minister and the Home Minister in the selection panel continues to cause concern. Critics argue that the central government’s significant influence in the panel can lead to an imbalance, as it may compromise the true independence of the Election Commission, making it vulnerable to political pressures.
2. Lack of Representation for Opposition: While the new law provides for the involvement of the Leader of the Opposition in the selection process, critics believe that the mechanism does not adequately empower the opposition to influence the appointment process. In the case where there is no recognized Leader of the Opposition (as may happen in a fragmented or majority government), this issue could undermine the fairness of the process.
3. Imbalance in Decision-Making: The absence of a broader, more diverse representation in the appointment process could lead to an imbalance in decision-making, giving undue weight to the ruling party’s influence over the Election Commission. This is particularly concerning in a country like India, where elections are often a matter of intense political competition.
4. Lack of Constitutional Backing for Some Provisions Some provisions of the Act could potentially conflict with the original intent of the Constitution. The Parliamentary system of impeachment, which is now a provision for the removal of the CEC or ECs, might not necessarily provide the degree of independence and protection that the Election Commission requires from executive or legislative interference.

Recommendations for Greater Independence of the ECI

1. Strengthening Opposition’s Role: Ensuring that the opposition has a more significant and structured role in the selection process would help prevent political bias from affecting appointments. This could include empowering a broader selection committee, with greater input from civil society and expert bodies.
2. Institutional Safeguards for Autonomy Incorporating stronger safeguards that protect the Commission from arbitrary political interference is essential. This could include provisions that allow the Election Commission to function with more independence from government interventions, especially during election periods.
3. Expanding Public Scrutiny: Increasing public oversight and scrutiny of the process of appointment and functioning of the Election Commission could be a crucial step toward reinforcing its credibility and reducing any chance of misuse.
4. Broader Stakeholder Consultation: Engaging various political parties, civil society organizations, and legal experts in the drafting of reforms could ensure a more inclusive and representative framework, balancing the interests of all stakeholders.

Conclusion:

As India approaches the 2024-2025 general elections, the Election Commission (CEC and ECs) Act, 2023 aims to enhance the Commission’s functioning and independence. However, concerns about political influence in appointments and the Commission’s autonomy persist. The recent appointment of the new Chief Election Commissioner and other members highlights these issues. To ensure the Election Commission remains impartial and effective, continued reforms, transparency, and safeguards are essential for upholding India’s democratic values.

Download Plutus IAS Current Affairs (Eng) 20th Feb 2025