Revised Appointment Process for Election Commissioners: A Step Towards Transparency

TRADITIONALLY, the successor to the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) has been the next senior Election Commissioner. For the first time, as per the Chief Election Commissioner And Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service And Term of Office) Act, 2023, the net can be cast wider. Current CEC Rajiv Kumar demits office on February 18. The Election Commission comprises the CEC and two election commissioners Gyanesh Kumar and Sukhbir Singh Sandhu at present.

Elections Commission of India strengthening India’s democracy:

1. Ensuring Free and Fair Elections: The ECI operates as an independent body, overseeing all elections to ensure impartiality. It enforces the Model Code of Conduct (MCC) to maintain electoral integrity and fairness.
2. Voter Representation: The ECI ensures universal adult suffrage, conducts voter education campaigns, and works to prevent disenfranchisement, especially among marginalized groups and youth.
3. Technological Innovations: Introduced Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs) and Voter Verifiable Paper Audit Trails (VVPAT) to enhance transparency. The proposed Remote Voting Machines (RVMs) aim to address the disenfranchisement of migrant workers.
4. Combating Criminalization: The ECI mandates the disclosure of criminal records by candidates, helping reduce the influence of criminals in politics.
5. Fostering Political Accountability: The ECI monitors campaign financing and political party activities, ensuring transparency and legal compliance.
6. Promoting Inclusivity: The ECI ensures adequate representation for marginalized groups, including women, and works towards increasing their political participation.
7. Ensuring Election Security: It collaborates with security agencies to prevent violence and electoral malpractices, ensuring peaceful elections, especially in conflict-prone areas.
8. Advocating for Electoral Reforms: The ECI advocates for reforms such as simultaneous elections and improved voter registration processes to enhance efficiency and reduce election-related disruptions.

Constitutional Mandate of Elections Commission of India:

1. Article 324: Grants the ECI the authority to supervise, direct, and control the entire election process in India, ensuring that elections are conducted impartially and fairly.
2. Articles 325–329: Establishes the framework for elections, including delimitation of constituencies and guarantees the right to vote for all eligible citizens, ensuring non-discrimination based on religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth.
3. Appointment and Tenure: The President of India appoints the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and Election Commissioners. Their tenure is safeguarded by law, ensuring their independence and preventing political interference.
4. Immunity from Dismissal: The Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) cannot be dismissed except by impeachment by Parliament, which ensures the independence of the office and prevents arbitrary removal by the government.

Role and power of the Elections Commission of India:

1. Supervising Elections: ECI oversees elections to Lok Sabha, State Assemblies, and Presidency, ensuring they are conducted impartially.
2. Delimitation of Constituencies: It ensures fair delimitation of constituencies based on population, maintaining equitable representation.
3. Regulating Political Parties and Candidates: ECI registers parties, enforces campaign laws, and ensures candidate eligibility.
4. Monitoring Campaigns: It enforces the Model Code of Conduct (MCC), ensuring ethical campaigning and preventing malpractice.
5. Voter Registration: The ECI maintains electoral rolls, ensuring all eligible citizens are registered and increasing voter participation.
6. Ensuring Election Security: It collaborates with authorities to maintain security, prevent violence, and deploy observers.
7. Technological Oversight: It manages the use of EVMs and VVPATs to ensure transparent voting.
8. Dispute Resolution: The ECI has the authority to resolve electoral disputes and take corrective actions when needed.

Independence of  Elections Commission of India:

1. Appointment Procedure: The President of India appoints the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) and Election Commissioners. Their tenure and independence are safeguarded by law to ensure impartial functioning.
2. Finance: The ECI is granted financial autonomy to prevent government interference. It is allocated its own budget by the Parliament, ensuring independence in executing its duties.
3. Manpower: The Election Commission has its own dedicated staff and officials to carry out election-related functions, ensuring independence from government influence in its operations.
4. Staff: The CEC and Election Commissioners are appointed for fixed tenures (typically six years or until they turn 65) and cannot be easily removed, protecting them from political pressures.
5. Suspensions: The CEC and Election Commissioners cannot be suspended or removed without due process. Only impeachment by Parliament can remove them, ensuring protection from arbitrary suspension.
6. Re-appointment: There is no provision for re-appointment of the CEC or Election Commissioners after their term ends, ensuring their independence by preventing potential political re-entry or influence.

Issues of the Elections Commission of India:

1. Executive Influence on Appointments:
Appointment Process: Appointments of CEC and ECs are made by the President on government advice, risking bias.
Lack of Bipartisanship: No consultative or bipartisan process, making the EC susceptible to political pressure.
2. Limited Safeguards for Independence:
Tenure: The CEC has tenure security, but other ECs can be removed by the CEC’s recommendation, lacking equal protection.
Service Conditions: CEC’s service conditions are protected, but other commissioners lack similar safeguards.
3. Financial Dependence:
Government Control: The EC’s budget is controlled by the government, compromising its financial autonomy.
4. Bureaucratization:
Dependence on Government Staff: The EC relies on central and state government staff, creating potential conflicts of interest.
5. Weak Enforcement of Model Code of Conduct (MCC):
No Statutory Backing: The MCC lacks legal enforceability, limiting the EC’s ability to act decisively.
6. Unclear Powers:
Transfer of Officials: The EC’s authority to transfer officials during elections clashes with state government control.
Administrative Interference: EC may disrupt government actions during elections, potentially affecting essential services.
7. Limited Control Over Political Parties:
Weak Party Regulation: The EC lacks the power to deregister parties or enforce internal democracy, undermining electoral integrity.
8. Executive Influence on Election Operations:
Central Armed Forces: Allegations of political influence on Central Armed Police Forces (CAPF), which could compromise election neutrality

Recommendation to promote the role of the Elections Commission of India:

1. Transparent, Bipartisan Appointment: Establish a collegium system for appointing CECs and ECs involving the PM, Leader of the Opposition, and Chief Justice of India.
2. Equal Protections for All Commissioners: Grant security of tenure and equal removal procedures for all ECs, similar to the CEC.
3. Financial Independence: Fund the EC through the Consolidated Fund of India to ensure autonomy in budget management.
4. Permanent Independent Secretariat: Set up a permanent, independent secretariat to reduce reliance on government staff.
5. Legalize the Model Code of Conduct (MCC): Provide statutory backing to the MCC, giving the EC full enforcement power.
6. Clarify EC’s Powers: Define EC’s authority over official transfers and administrative interference during elections.
7. Regulate Political Parties: Empower the EC to deregister parties for violations and enforce internal party democracy.
8. Ensure Neutrality in Election Security: Safeguard the Central Armed Police Forces from political influence during elections.

Conclusion

The Election Commission of India (ECI) plays a pivotal role in strengthening India’s democracy by ensuring free, fair, and transparent elections. While it has made significant strides in promoting electoral integrity, the ECI faces challenges such as executive influence, limited safeguards for independence, financial dependence, and bureaucratization. To address these challenges and further enhance its role, it is essential to implement reforms that focus on transparent and bipartisan appointments, equal protections for all Election Commissioners, financial autonomy, and a permanent independent secretariat. Additionally, legalizing the Model Code of Conduct (MCC), empowering the EC to regulate political parties, and ensuring neutrality in election security will contribute to a more robust and impartial election process.

Prelims Question: