27 Jul Do Not Surrender to China, Do Not Depend on the U.S.

Why in the News?

Shashi Tharoor argues that India should avoid both economic dependence on China and strategic overreliance on the United States, advocating instead a policy of strategic autonomy, economic resilience, and military preparedness.

---

Background

• Uncertainty in U.S. foreign policy, particularly under changing administrations, has revived debates in India over resetting relations with China.
• Some business groups advocate easing tensions with China to reduce economic costs and restore trade.
• The article argues that such a reset ignores China’s long-term strategic behaviour and India’s national security concerns.

---

Why Some Advocate a China Reset?

Economic Arguments

• Reduce supply chain disruptions.
• Improve access to cheaper Chinese machinery and industrial inputs.
• Boost manufacturing competitiveness.
• Ease inflationary pressures.
• Restore pre-2020 trade relations.

---

Why the Author Opposes a China Reset

1. China’s Aggressive Border Behaviour

The article argues that China has consistently attempted to alter the status quo through:

• Depsang (2013)
• Chumar (2014)
• Doklam (2017)
• Galwan Valley clashes (2020)

According to the author, China continues:

• Salami-slicing tactics along the Line of Actual Control (LAC)
• Territorial claims over Arunachal Pradesh
• Issuing stapled visas to residents of Arunachal Pradesh and Jammu & Kashmir
• Renaming places in Arunachal Pradesh
• Political pressure through border disputes.

---

2. Economic Coercion as a Strategic Tool

China has allegedly used trade and manufacturing dominance to:

• Restrict exports of critical industrial inputs.
• Leverage its dominance in rare earth elements.
• Create dependence through supply chains.
• Use economic power for political influence.

Key Concern: Economic dependence can become a strategic vulnerability during crises.

---

3. Strategic Alignment with Pakistan

The article highlights that China:

• Provides military assistance to Pakistan.
• Shares defence technology and intelligence.
• Strengthens Pakistan’s military capabilities.
• Uses Pakistan as a strategic counterweight against India.

---

The Myth of Economic Reciprocity

The article rejects the assumption that:

If India relaxes economic restrictions, China will reciprocate politically.

Instead, it argues that:

• China’s foreign policy is driven by strategic objectives rather than commercial concessions.
• Trade concessions are unlikely to change Beijing’s territorial positions.
• China separates economic cooperation from geopolitical disputes.

---

Concerns Over China’s Regional Strategy

According to the article, China has:

• Blocked India’s bid for permanent membership in the UN Security Council (UNSC).
• Opposed India’s entry into the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG).
• Shielded Pakistan-based terrorists in international forums.
• Expanded influence across South Asia and the Indo-Pacific.

---

Risks of Excessive Economic Dependence

The article warns that greater dependence on Chinese imports could:

• Increase India’s trade deficit.
• Expose industries to supply disruptions.
• Reduce strategic autonomy.
• Give China economic leverage during conflicts.

---

Why India Should Not Overdepend on the U.S.

The article also cautions against assuming the United States will always guarantee India’s security because:

• U.S. foreign policy changes with administrations.
• American priorities are driven by its own national interests.
• India must prepare to defend its own strategic interests independently.

---

The Suggested Strategic Path for India

The author recommends a policy of Strategic Autonomy, including:

Economic Measures

• Diversify supply chains.
• Reduce dependence on Chinese imports.
• Strengthen domestic manufacturing.
• Promote self-reliance in critical technologies.

Strategic Measures

• Enhance military preparedness.
• Build resilient infrastructure along borders.
• Deepen partnerships with Europe, East Asia, ASEAN, and the Global South.
• Maintain balanced relations with both the U.S. and China without excessive dependence.

---

Key UPSC Concepts

Strategic Autonomy

India’s foreign policy principle of making independent strategic decisions without aligning exclusively with any major power.

Economic Security

Protecting national interests by reducing vulnerabilities arising from excessive dependence on foreign economies for critical goods and technologies.

Supply Chain Resilience

Diversifying production and sourcing to reduce risks from geopolitical conflicts or economic coercion.

Salami Slicing

A strategy of making incremental territorial advances that individually appear minor but cumulatively alter the status quo.

---

Constitutional & Policy Linkages

• Article 51: Promotion of international peace and security.
• Atmanirbhar Bharat: Reducing external dependence in strategic sectors.
• Make in India: Strengthening domestic manufacturing.
• National Security Strategy (proposed): Integrating economic and military resilience.
• Act East Policy & Indo-Pacific Vision: Diversifying strategic partnerships.

---

Critical Analysis

Strengths of the Argument

• Emphasizes national security alongside economic interests.
• Highlights the strategic risks of excessive dependence.
• Supports India’s long-standing doctrine of strategic autonomy.
• Recognizes both military and economic dimensions of national power.

Counter-Arguments

• Complete economic decoupling from China is difficult given deep trade integration.
• Selective engagement with China may be necessary for economic growth.
• Cooperation on global issues such as climate change and multilateral institutions requires continued diplomatic engagement.
• India’s balancing strategy benefits from maintaining strong ties with multiple major powers.

---

Conclusion

The article argues that India’s long-term national interest lies in strategic autonomy, avoiding both economic dependence on China and security dependence on the United States. It advocates strengthening domestic capabilities, diversifying economic partnerships, and maintaining a balanced foreign policy that safeguards India’s sovereignty and strategic interests.

---

UPSC Prelims Practice Question

Q. Which of the following best describes the concept of “Strategic Autonomy” in India’s foreign policy?

1. Joining a formal military alliance with major powers.
2. Maintaining independent decision-making while engaging with multiple countries.
3. Pursuing complete economic isolation from all major economies.
4. Depending exclusively on one strategic partner for national security.

Select the correct answer:

(a) 1 only
(b) 2 only
(c) 1 and 4 only
(d) 2 and 3 only

Answer: (b)

Explanation: Strategic autonomy means preserving independent foreign policy decision-making while engaging with multiple partners without entering exclusive alliances.